>>  General Information
>>  About Us
>>  Practice Areas
>>  Attorney Profile
>>  Newsletter
>>  Publications
>>  Florida Locations
>>  Employment
>>  Important Links
>>  Press Release
>>  Seminar Information
>>  Clients: Update Your Info
>>  Legal Services And Fees
>>  Legislative Updates
>>  Trade Show Vendors
>>  E-Mail Us
>>  Return to Home Page



Association Developments

4th Quarter Volume XII

2000

a service provided by Clayton & McCulloh


UNDERSTANDING THE HOA CREATURE



Today most houses and residences being sold in Florida are subject to such governing documents because they are part of a subdivision governed by an Association. Unfortunately, all too often, the closing agent, the attorneys, the sellers, and the realtors fail to disclose - much less point out the existence of a Homeowners Association and the ramifications of having a mandatory Homeowners Association. Understand the Homeowners Association is here for your benefit. It is here to protect and preserve your property values and ensure that all of your neighbors comply with the Governing documents so that you are not subjected to certain improper conduct and unwanted behavior.



In communities with mandatory Membership Associations which are subject to such governing documents, each owner basically gives up certain rights so that they can acquire significant protections. Part of these protections exist by virtue of requiring certain activities of your neighbors. These protections and the restrictions are laid out in the governing documents. However, by way of example, most people do not want to live next to:



1. a junk yard;

see Creature, pg 2

 

HEAR YE! HEAR YE! TIPS FOR SUCCESSFUL BOARD MEETING


Having a successful board meeting takes time, thought, and preparation. Unfortunately, too many times, directors hold board meetings and just "show up" without any forethought or preparation. When your board holds meeting in this fashion, little is accomplished and you are not using your time effectively.


Before scheduling a board meeting, draft and provide your fellow directors with an agenda with notes in advance. Try to give your other board members at least ten days advance notice. Also, distribute reports at the same time. By giving all the other board members the documents and materials they need in advance, you will sharply curtail the time your meeting takes. Board meetings should not drag on for hours. The maximum time allotted for a board meeting should be one and one-half hours. People tend to lose interest and their efficiency after that time. If you

see Meetings, pg 4


 

4th Quarter 2000 Page Two Volume XII


MANDATORY ASSOCIATIONS HELP KEEP PROPERTY VALUES UP

Creature (from pg 1)



2. a house with blazing neon signs; and



3. a house painted purple with pink polka dots



One of the reasons why people do not want to live in a community with these type of activities is because the property values have a tendency to plummet. Therefore, the laws of the State of Florida have created a means of protecting the owners, and in fact, have provided the owners through the Association with a vehicle to enforce these rights. While it is anticipated that nobody will like each and every provision set forth within the governing documents, in general the governing documents should benefit each and every one of the owners. However, even if this was not the case, each and every owner would still be required, by law, to comply with the provisions of the governing documents and the Florida Statutes. The reasons that compliance is mandatory and even required by law is recited below.



The Declaration of Covenants and Restrictions constitutes in the nature of a "covenant running with the land". Generally, this means that purchasers and tenants, have record title notice of the existence of that Declaration and have agreed to abide by each and every term set forth therein. Many owners may say "but I did not know of the existence of the Declaration" or "no one told me of the existence of the Declaration". While such statements may be true, the responsibility for knowing of the existence of the Declaration lies with the owner and the tenant.



Generally, the Declaration of Covenants and Restrictions are recorded in the county records prior to the time that each and every one of the Lot owners took title to their Lot(s). Hence, you did have record title notice of the existence of the restrictions. Additionally, by virtue of the Declaration being recorded prior in time to the deed by which each owner took title to his Lot, the Declaration takes precedence over the deed. Therefore, each owner by law tacitly agrees when he purchases a Lot that he will abide by the Declaration. Understand the Declaration is in the nature of a super contract between the Association and each of the owners. In fact, if you question the enforceability of the Declaration, please pull out your own title insurance policy. Within it you most likely will see that title to your property is subject to the Declaration of Covenants and Restrictions (i.e. the title policy does not insure the owner against the requirements of the Declaration).


In addition to the fact that your Declaration constitutes a covenant running with the land and is therefore enforceable, the Florida Statutes have expressly mandated that:


1. each owner, tenant and guest shall comply with the governing documents (i.e. Declaration, Articles of Incorporation and Bylaws, etc.); and



  • That the governing documents may be enforced against owners, tenants and guests by the Association.


Obligations of members; remedies at law or in equity; ...



(1) Each member and the member's tenants, guests, and invitees, and each association, are governed by, and must comply with, this chapter, the governing documents of the community, and the rules of the association. Actions at law or in equity, or both, to redress alleged failure or refusal to

see Creature, pg 3



4th Quarter 2000 Page Three Volume XII


BOARD MEMBERS ARE ELECTED TO MAKE TOUGH DECISIONS - NOT TO BE THE MOST POPULAR PERSON IN THE COMMUNITY!

Creature (from pg 2)





comply with these provisions may be brought by the association or by any member against:



    • The association;


    • A member;


    • Any director or officer of an association who willfully and knowingly fails to comply with these provisions; and


    • Any tenants, guests, or invitees occupying a parcel of using the common areas.


The prevailing party in any such litigation is entitled to recover reasonable attorney's fees and costs. This section does not deprive any person of any other available right or remedy. (emphasis added)





Please understand that the reference to "Member" in the above Statute equates to and means the "owner" of a Lot. Given the above, a violation of the Declaration constitutes a violation of the Florida Statutes (i.e. it is unlawful). Therefore, any time someone violates the Declaration, they are also violating the Florida law.



Often we see individuals who want their Board of Directors to ignore the Covenants. Please do not request this of your Board of Directors as they have a fiduciary duty which ostensibly includes endeavoring to abide by the Documents and the Florida Statutes. Understand each of the other owners has a right to expect that the Documents will be enforced for their protection. Nevertheless, please understand that the Association is not an insurance company which guarantees that no violation shall ever occur. Rather, the Association intends to compel compliance and require compliance as soon as it learns of a violation. Additionally, often we hear the defense "this violation occurred prior to my purchasing the house". Understand, by virtue of the Declaration constituting a covenant running with the land, it is the Lot in addition to the activities of the owners or residents which must be in compliance. Therefore, if a violation is discovered later with respect to your Lot, the Association ostensibly has the right to enforce compliance regardless of ownership. This of course, means the owner of the Lot who currently exists may bare the brunt and the burden of such compliance. Remember, you as the purchaser had record title notice of the existence of the Declaration and what was required. By way of example, if Owner 1 failed to pay his assessments and then sold his house to Owner 2. This law firm would generally apprise Owner 2 of the delinquency of that Lot's account and request Owner 2 to bring it current. If Owner 2 did not bring the account current, then the Association has the right to lien the property and ultimately foreclose and take the house for delinquent and unpaid assessments. Understand that in the above scenario the law firm would not even be talking to Owner 1. Rather, we would be communicating with the current owner even though the delinquency arose prior to his purchasing the Lot. Please further understand that the current owner may have significant rights to go back against

see Creature, pg 4


 

4th Quarter 2000 Page Four Volume XII


CREATE HARMONY BY WORKING HAND IN HAND

Creature (from pg 3)



the seller, the title company, the closing agent, a realtor, another attorney, etc. Conversely, the Association should endeavor to collect the funds in the easiest manner available. Generally, this will be via a lien and foreclosure proceeding which goes against the Lot regardless of the owner. Please understand that the above is not meant to be threatening, rather it is provided as a means of explaining why each and every owner, occupant and guest must comply with all of the covenants and restrictions set forth in the Governing Documents (i.e., why the Governing Documents must be followed).



Please work with your Association to make your community the best it can be, to protect its property values, and have a harmonious, congenial community. Please do not allow violations to exist as the Association may be compelled to turn the matter over to this firm to compel compliance. We do not wish this to occur. However, in the event of violations, the Association and this law firm intend to act responsibly and compel compliance for the benefit of the entire community.

 


NEW ANNUAL MEETING PACKAGE

AVAILABLE



In addition to our standard Annual Meeting Package ($150.00), we now offer the Deluxe Annual Meeting Package which includes in addition to preparing the documents in accordance with the Florida Statutes and your governing documents, one of our associate attorneys will also attend your annual meeting for up to three hours (including travel time). Our partners, Ken Clayton and Neal McCulloh, are not included in

this package. If you would like one of them to attend your meeting, please call for a quote for one of the partners to attend your annual meeting. This new Deluxe Annual Meeting Package is $450.00. If you have any questions regarding this new service, please call Arlene-Frances Ring at any of our offices.




Place Time Limits on Owners Speaking

Meetings (from pg 1)



are taking more time than that, you are possibly guilty of one of the following things:



  • Placing too many items on the agenda. Consider having workshops with your committees if necessary prior to the board meeting when undertaking a large project.


  • Not limiting/budgeting time for each subject.


  • When drafting the agenda, place time limits for each subject and place those limits next to each item. Try to limit the scope of discussion for each topic. You will probably have to review the agenda each month to make a determination of how much time each topic needs. Rehearse in your mind what you are going to say. Don't let people ramble on.


  • Allowing owners too much participation in the meeting. While you do not want to alienate owners from attending, for everyone's benefit, you should limit their speaking time to two minutes.


  • Don't discuss a topic that is not on the agenda. If a topic comes up that needs to be discussed, place it on the next meeting's agenda. Keep to the agenda!

see Meetings, pg 5




4th Quarter 2000 Page Five Volume XII


HOLD MEETINGS ON REGULAR BASIS

Meetings (from pg 5)



One of your goals should be to encourage your members to attend the board meetings, thus creating more community involvement. Post your meetings as required by your governing documents and the Florida Statutes, and then encourage member participation. You may even want to give additional time for notices to be posted. For example, if your documents require forty-eight hours notice, consider giving one week notice in addition to the required notice. Make the meeting accessible to the members. Members are very hesitant to attend board meetings which take place in directors' homes. Many business establishments will provide you with free meeting space to hold your board and/or annual meetings. Some examples of establishments which offer complimentary meeting rooms are: Publix, the county libraries, churches, local schools, and malls.



Some people believe that the president should never cast a vote on an issue unless there is a tie. This belief is false. You not only can, but should, vote on every issue that comes before the board. However, you should abstain from voting on an issue if there is a conflict of interest. For example, if the Board is voting on giving a contract for landscaping to one of your relatives. It may be the best bid that you have received, but you have a personal interest in your relative getting that contract. In that event, not only should you abstain from voting, it might be prudent to leave the room when the vote takes place.


Become acquainted with Robert's Rules of Order. This is especially important if you are the president. You do not have to know every single point of order, but become familiar so you can competently conduct a meeting with authority and poise. The time will come when you will have a "problem meeting." To anticipate this time, buy a gavel and use it when the need arises. It can be a valuable tool in getting people's attention and restoring order to the meeting.


Schedule your board meetings on a regular basis. You may need to meet only once a quarter or once a month. Some associations choose to meet weekly after a new board has been elected and then taper off. Whatever time frame you select (unless your documents mandate when your meetings will be), keep them consistent, and always properly notice them.


The above tips are just a few suggestions for having successful board meetings. When trying to create your own ideas, review what has been done in the past and use it as a "building block" for better board meetings. Above all, remember that you are a director of a corporation, and even though it may be a not for profit corporation, it is still a corporation and should be treated as a business.


4th Quarter 2000 Page Six Volume XII


COVENANT ENFORCEMENT OF "COMMERCIAL ACTIVITY"

IN THE NEW MILLENNIUM



Most declarations of covenants and conditions prohibit commercial activity from transpiring within the community. This is typically true whether you reside in a condominium association, a homeowner association or a cooperative. The primary motivation behind such restrictions is to protect the residential character of the community.


Many types of activities have been determined by the courts to constitute commercial activity in violation of a particular association's governing documents. In some recent cases, courts have associated certain types of vehicles with prohibited commercial activity. In one case, the court associated the vehicles and trailers used in a landscaping business with commercial activity and enjoined the use of the property for the storage of landscaping materials and the parking of the vehicles. In another case, a court found that the parking of limousines used for both personal and commercial use was a violation of the declaration and enjoined the owner from parking the limousines on the property.


Unfortunately for associations, however, the line between commercial use and residential use is not always clear. At least one court has held that the operation of a licensed adult congregate living facility was not a commercial use of the property. The court made this determination despite the owners admitted profit motive in operating the facility. Other courts have held that the operation of a licensed day-care facility is not commercial activity. It appears that the common thread running through these decisions is that the operation of an adult congregate living facility or a day-care center are consistent with a residential use of the property. Conversely, at least one Florida Circuit Court has held that the short term rental of property is commercial activity notwithstanding the fact that the occupants of the property are utilizing the property for brief residential purposes. In this short term rental case, one factor which appeared to convince the trial judge that the activity was commercial was the profit motive of the owners.


It is very likely that disputes between owners and associations over what is or what is not commercial activity and what is or is not residential activity will increase in the future. With the advent of computers, the Internet, on-line-services, and tele-commuting, the possibility exists that a resident could manage and operate from home a very large and successful business. The type of business which could be operated from a home computer may include anything from marketing or information services to wholesale and retail operations. As with the Internet itself, the possibilities are almost limitless.

When faced with this type of dispute in the future, it is likely that courts may look at the impact of the home occupation upon the other residents and upon the common elements of the association. For instance, a court may be more likely to find a home occupation which results in a greater traffic flow of either customers or delivery trucks to be commercial activity than a home occupation which operates solely through the telephone lines. In the future, the technical and legal distinctions which have evolved in the law regarding what is or is not commercial activity may no longer apply. In the new millennium, what is or is not commercial activity may depend more upon the impact the activity has upon the other residents and the common areas of the association than on any antiquated notions of what is or is not commercial activity.


In the future, associations, association managers, and association counsel should not necessarily rely upon prior case law in evaluating whether or not a particular activity is commercial. After all, it is quite possible that the law may be different in the new millennium.

 


General Information     About Us     Practice Areas     Attorney Profile     Newsletter     Publications     Florida Locations     Employment     Important Links

  Press Release     Seminar Information     Clients: Update Your Info     Legal Services and Fees     Legislative Updates     E-Mail Us     Home Page

IMPORTANT NOTICE. The hiring of a lawyer is an important decision that should not be based solely upon advertisements. Before you decide, ask us to send you free written information about our qualifications and experience. This web site presents general information about the law firm of Clayton & McCulloh and is not intended as legal advice nor should you consider it as such.  Although we welcome your calls, letters and e-mail, please keep in mind that merely contacting our office will not establish an attorney-client relationship between us.  Consequently, you should not convey any confidential information to us until a formal attorney-client relationship has been established.

 

Copyright © 2008 by Clayton & McCulloh.  All rights reserved.